One of my biggest goals in wifehood (is that a real thing?) is to become the better gift giver.
Yeah, it’s a competition. Historically, one I’ve always lost, which is why there’s been need for change. Or shall I say, which is why I have consciously changed things around here. I did well my first Christmas as a wife, but I knew I’d have to step it up for my (new!) husband’s January 9 birthday.
I had heard about a little place just outside Green Bay, Wisconsin with to-die-for dinner options and a chef’s table. So, I made a reservation at Chives, 1749 Riverside Drive, Suamaco, which is rumored to be Aaron Rodgers’ favorite dinner place when he’s in town. Legend has it, the chef’s table was created just for him.
The cost of the table – for 2 or for 12 – is $65 per person (plus a bottle of wine, in our case, duh) and is worth every penny.
When we arrived, the chef, JR, came over to tell us how the evening would go. He’d just cook us a bunch of stuff, he said. And we’d eat. I. AM. IN.

First course: Fried Oysters with Vegetable Slaw and Remoulade (menu price $18). Sadly, I was so excited for the food to start coming that I forgot to snap a photo of the first course. I know, right? Anyway, I don’t think I’ve ever tried an oyster before because I think I though you had to slurp them out of a shell and I was never really interested. However, the dish wasn’t like what I had in my head about oysters. These were perfectly breaded and cooked, not fishy or slimy at all and had a great flavor. I liked how the zing from the slaw balanced the dish.
Second course: Grilled Asparagus with Miso Butter, Bacon and Poached Egg (menu price $10). I have always, always been an asparagus fan, so I was really excited when I caught a glimpse of this dish being prepared. This was amazing, one of my favorite courses, even. I was worried about Jeff on this one because he can be a little weird with runny eggs, but he too loved the dish.

Third course: We didn’t find this course on the regular menu. It was a porchini mushroom sauce over fresh wide noodle pasta topped with truffle oil and foie gras shavings. Jeff hates mushrooms, and always has, with all of his being. It’s the one food he won’t eat. He, with all of his being, loved this dish. Several times he called it, “earthy,” and he was right.

Fourth course: French Style Flounder with Artichoke and Pico (a similar menu item was priced at $32). I’ll always order the fish dish, so I was glad when this was placed in front of me. JR said the fish is breaded opposite from what you would expect. Flour, then egg, he said.The photo expresses my excitement over the fish; I almost forgot to take a photo!

Fifth course: The meat course. JR and his crew (which, by the way is totally a well-oiled machine. The kitchen is quiet, well traveled around and through, cordial. Our waiter told us that many of them have worked at Chivers for five plus years, and they really are a family.) prepared us a cracked pepper tenderloin with a brandy sauce. It was served with home fries and green beans. The steak was cooked more rare than I would have ever prepared a steak for myself. However, it was tender, not bloody and flavorful. I loved it.


Dessert course: It was our lucky day (or perhaps the fact we had Birthday Boy in the house). We were served two desserts!

One of the desserts was a pana cotta with a bourbon sauce. I liked it. It was smooth and sweet. However, the Smores Creme Brule stole the show for me. It was, hands down, my favorite part of the meal. This is very surprising because I am never the dessert person. The marshmallow and graham crackers were even home made.

Everything was so great that we’d love to try Chives again. We’d like to go back and eat dinner off of their regular menu sometime.
JR was an all-around nice guy, sharing tidbits about the dishes and stories with us. I think the interaction was a really nice touch for a special evening like Jeff’s birthday. At the end of our meal, I asked him if he’d take a photo with us.

Side note, cool thing: JR and his wife run a fantastic nonprofit called Seven Loaves Project. During our dinner, he brought over his iPad so we could learn a little more about the project, which essentially builds bakeries so people in Africa have something to eat.

The experience was great, the food was amazing, the setting was cool and I think I might even win the best gift award. The Birthday Boy has been talkin’ about dinner since we left. Love it.
(Happy (early) Birthday, Jeff. I love you!)
